Senate Rejects Order to Pull U.S. Forces From Hostilities With Iran, 48-51. What the Resolution Would Have Done
The Senate on Thursday rejected a House-passed concurrent resolution directing the president to remove U.S. forces from hostilities with Iran. Republicans Susan Collins, Lisa Murkowski and Rand Paul voted yes; Democrat John Fetterman voted no. Thom Tillis, a yes in September, voted no.

The Overview
The facts, straight
The Senate on Thursday rejected a resolution ordering U.S. forces out of hostilities with Iran, 48-51, with one senator not voting (Senate Roll Call Vote 269; Senate Daily Press). Three Republicans voted yes: Susan Collins of Maine, Lisa Murkowski of Alaska and Rand Paul of Kentucky. Sen. John Fetterman of Pennsylvania was the only Democrat to vote no, and Sen. Chris Murphy of Connecticut didn't vote. Independents Angus King of Maine and Bernie Sanders of Vermont voted yes. The roll call opened at 2 p.m. ET and the result was posted at 2:42 p.m. ET.
Because the Senate didn't adopt it, the resolution dies. A concurrent resolution has to pass both chambers in identical form, and it would never have gone to the president.
The measure was H.Con.Res. 93, a concurrent resolution from Rep. Seth Moulton, a Massachusetts Democrat. The House adopted it 220-204 late on Sept. 15 (House Clerk, Roll Call 307). Seven Republicans voted yes: Reps. Tom Barrett, Warren Davidson, Brian Fitzpatrick, Nancy Mace, Thomas Massie, Mariannette Miller-Meeks and Zach Nunn. Every Democrat who voted said yes. Rep. Kevin Kiley, listed by the Clerk as an independent, voted no.
Why the Senate voted. On Nov. 10, senators agreed by unanimous consent that, no later than Friday, Nov. 20, the resolution would be pulled out of the Foreign Relations Committee and brought to the floor, with up to six hours of debate split between the two parties' leaders and then a vote on adoption (Senate Daily Press wrap-up, Nov. 10). Sens. Peter Welch, Tammy Baldwin, Tim Kaine and Tim Sheehy spoke about Iran on the floor before the vote, according to the Daily Press log.
What it would have done. The resolution's text, as passed by the House, invokes Section 5(c) of the War Powers Resolution and "directs the President to remove United States Armed Forces from hostilities against the Islamic Republic of Iran." It makes exceptions:
- Forces "necessary to defend the United States or an ally or partner of the United States from imminent attack" can stay, provided the president fully complies with the War Powers Resolution's Section 5(b), its 60-to-90-day clock.
- The directive doesn't apply if Congress passes a declaration of war or "a specific congressional authorization for use of military force against Iran."
The September vote. The Senate has voted on this before. On Sept. 24 it rejected a similar House measure, H.Con.Res. 89, 49-50 (Senate Roll Call Vote 244). Four Republicans voted yes: Susan Collins of Maine, Lisa Murkowski of Alaska, Rand Paul of Kentucky and Thom Tillis of North Carolina. Sen. John Fetterman of Pennsylvania was the only Democrat to vote no, and Sen. Angela Alsobrooks of Maryland didn't vote. On Thursday, Tillis voted no. That one switch accounts for the difference between September's 49-50 and Thursday's 48-51.
What it couldn't have done anyway. Unlike a bill or a joint resolution, a concurrent resolution doesn't go to the president, so he can't sign or veto it. The Congressional Research Service says that makes Section 5(c) "constitutionally suspect" under the Supreme Court's 1983 ruling in INS v. Chadha, which struck down a legislative veto. The Court held that this kind of action requires "passage by a majority of both Houses and presentment to the President." CRS notes that some legal analysts argue war powers are a special case. It also points to 1993, when the House considered a Section 5(c) resolution on Somalia: both the sponsor and then-Speaker Tom Foley said it would be nonbinding because of Chadha. A separate 1983 law (50 U.S.C. 1546a) gives Congress fast-track procedures for a joint resolution ordering a withdrawal. A joint resolution goes to the president and can be vetoed.
Cost and the calendar. The vote came during a fight over war funding. The Washington Post reported Thursday that Senate Republicans are pausing President Donald Trump's request to pass $350 billion in defense money through a party-line bill and will first try to negotiate with Democrats, after what the Post called midterm backlash over the Iran war. CBS News quoted Majority Leader John Thune calling it an "open question" whether Republicans have the votes, and reported that Democrats take control of the Senate in the new year. Government funding runs out Dec. 11 under the current stopgap law.
For background on the House's fight over Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth and the war, see our earlier story: Massie Plans to Force a House Vote on Impeaching Hegseth. More coverage: Iran war.
What the Left Says
The progressive and Democratic case
Democrats backing the resolution frame it as Congress taking back its Article I power to decide on war, and they point to the war's cost and casualties.
Sen. Elizabeth Warren of Massachusetts said she asked the Navy secretary nominee "what $47B spent on the Iran war could do for Americans," and listed student debt, pre-K and medical debt. "We must end this war NOW," she wrote. The $47 billion figure is hers.
Sen. Jeff Merkley of Oregon wrote, "We've lost 23 servicemembers because of Trump's illegal war in Iran. More than 800 servicemembers have been injured." He called it a "war of choice." The casualty figures and the claim that the war is illegal are Merkley's.
Where Reality Likely Sits
Radio Purple's analysis
- The Senate has now said no twice. Both Senate votes on Iran war powers resolutions this fall fell short: 49-50 in September and 48-51 on Thursday. Collins, Murkowski and Paul voted yes both times and Fetterman voted no both times. Tillis moved from yes to no.
- Passage wouldn't have settled the legal question. The president never signs a concurrent resolution. CRS calls the Section 5(c) route constitutionally suspect after Chadha. The same CRS report notes that "some legal analysts contend" the War Powers Resolution is "in a unique category" apart from other legislative vetoes. Passage would have put both chambers on record against continuing the hostilities. Stopping the war by law would take a joint resolution or a funding limit, and the president could veto either one.
- Troop safety was written into the text. Both sides cite troops. The resolution would have kept forces needed to defend the U.S. and its allies and partners from imminent attack, so it wasn't an order to pull out every U.S. service member in the region.
- Money is now the main lever. The Pentagon request and the Dec. 11 funding deadline give Congress a separate tool, the power of the purse, that doesn't raise the Chadha problem.
What the Right Says
The conservative and Republican case
Republicans are split.
Sen. Tom Cotton of Arkansas, who opposes the resolution, wrote that "Democrats want to end the war by surrendering to Iran, unilaterally raising the white flag, and allowing terrorists to control the Strait of Hormuz," adding: "America needs a victory strategy, not an exit strategy."
Sen. Rand Paul of Kentucky, who voted yes on both Senate war powers resolutions, argues against the war on cost grounds. On Nov. 18, writing about the proposed new war funding, not the war powers resolution, he said he is "the only Republican senator in opposition to voting for another $450 billion for the Iran War right now." Collins and Murkowski joined him in voting for Thursday's resolution. Paul uses $450 billion. The Post and CBS put the Pentagon request at $350 billion.
Sources & Citations
- Office of the Clerk, U.S. House of Representatives, “Roll Call 307: H.Con.Res. 93, On Agreeing to the Resolution”, September 15, 2026.
- U.S. Government Publishing Office, “H.Con.Res. 93 (Engrossed in House)”, September 15, 2026.
- U.S. Government Publishing Office, “H.Con.Res. 93 (Introduced in House)”, April 28, 2026.
- U.S. Senate, “Roll Call Vote 119th Congress, 2nd Session, Vote 269: H.Con.Res. 93”, November 19, 2026.
- U.S. Senate, “Roll Call Vote 119th Congress, 2nd Session, Vote 244: H.Con.Res. 89”, September 24, 2026.
- U.S. Senate Daily Press, “Tuesday, November 10, 2026 (floor wrap-up)”, November 10, 2026.
- U.S. Senate Daily Press, “Senate floor log, Thursday, November 19, 2026 (vote result, 2:42 p.m. ET)”, November 19, 2026.
- Congressional Research Service (via EveryCRSReport), “The War Powers Resolution: Concepts and Practice (R42699)”, March 8, 2019.
- The Washington Post, “Senate Republicans resist Trump's bid to bypass Democrats on defense funding”, November 19, 2026.
- CBS News, “Thune says it's still an 'open question' whether Senate GOP can pass massive defense bill”, November 18, 2026.
Positions above are attributed to the public statements and published reporting cited here. Quotations are taken from these sources; Radio Purple does not publish unattributed or invented quotes. See an error? Request a correction.


