USDA Proposes Ending Broad-Based SNAP Eligibility; Its Own Analysis Says 6.3 Million People Would Lose Benefits
A proposed rule would limit automatic SNAP eligibility to households receiving TANF 'assistance.' USDA projects 3.2 million households would no longer get benefits once the change fully takes hold in fiscal 2029, and $44.6 billion less in federal benefit spending over five years. Comments are due Dec. 10.

The Overview
The facts, straight
The Agriculture Department has formally proposed ending "broad-based categorical eligibility," a policy that lets states automatically qualify households for SNAP, the food assistance program once called food stamps, when they receive even a nominal benefit or service funded by the Temporary Assistance for Needy Families (TANF) block grant.
Under the proposed rule, published Nov. 10, only households receiving TANF "assistance," as defined in federal regulations, would remain categorically eligible. Others would have to meet SNAP's federal income and asset limits directly. The rule's burden estimates count 45 states using the broader approach and note that Alaska adopted it in July 2025, which makes 46.
USDA's own regulatory impact analysis puts numbers on the change. Each one measures something specific:
- People and households. About 16.9% of participating households, or 17.6% of participants, "would no longer receive SNAP benefits because their income or resources exceed the Federal statutory limits." That is more than 3.2 million households containing 6.3 million people in fiscal 2029, the first year USDA expects the rule to reach full effect. It is a one-year estimate, not a five-year total.
- Federal benefit spending. About $44.6 billion less in federal SNAP benefits over fiscal 2027 through 2031. After about $309.5 million more in federal reimbursement of state administrative costs, the net federal reduction is about $44.3 billion.
- States. A net reduction of about $5.2 billion in state SNAP spending over the same five years: about $6.2 billion less in state benefit costs under the 2025 budget law's new cost-sharing, partly offset by about $929 million in added state administrative costs.
- School meals. About 1.78 million children would no longer be automatically eligible for free school meals in what USDA calls school year 2029. USDA estimates about 97% would remain eligible for free or reduced-price meals based on income. It projects 1.66 million would still get free meals, 93,000 would move to reduced price and 28,000 would pay full price.
- Other programs. About 42,000 children could stop receiving Summer EBT starting in summer 2029, including about 13,000 USDA expects would remain eligible but not apply. About 5,500 WIC participants would lose eligibility.
Timing. This is a proposal; it sets no effective date. The analysis assumes the change would start Oct. 1, 2027, apply as households apply or recertify, and reach the full caseload in fiscal 2029.
How to comment. Comments are due Dec. 10, 2026, "to be assured of consideration." Readers can comment on the Regulations.gov docket by opening the proposed rule and selecting "Comment." The rule also lists email (sm.fn.snappdbrules@usda.gov, with the docket number and rule title in the subject line) and mail to the SNAP Program Development Division in Beltsville, Maryland.
USDA published a separate proposed rule the same day to codify the 2025 budget law's changes to SNAP's time limit for adults subject to work requirements. Its comments are also due Dec. 10.
What the Left Says
The progressive and Democratic case
Democrats and anti-hunger groups call the proposal a benefit cut dressed up as integrity.
"This move by the Trump administration to take food assistance away from millions more elderly Americans and children is heartless and cruel," House Agriculture Committee ranking Democrat Angie Craig of Minnesota said in a statement. "The proposed rule would make it harder to meet basic needs and roll back efforts to streamline federal programs."
Rep. Jahana Hayes of Connecticut, the top Democrat on the House nutrition subcommittee, said: "This change does not aim to mitigate fraud or abuse – it is to inflict harm on families struggling to get by." Both offices note that 46 states, led by both parties, use the policy.
Post: Sen. Cory Booker (@SenBooker) on X, Nov. 9, 2026.
The Food Research & Action Center said eliminating the policy "does nothing to reduce hunger, and it doesn't improve program integrity," warned that "the impact could be far worse than projected," and objected that "only giving the public 30 days to comment" is too short. FRAC also says Congress "reconsidered and rejected these very cuts" during last year's budget reconciliation; that is FRAC's characterization.
Post: Center on Budget (@CenterOnBudget) on X, Nov. 10, 2026.
Gina Plata-Nino, FRAC's SNAP director, told CBS News: "Basically, what the administration is doing is continuing on this path of making sure that SNAP is dismantled."
Where Reality Likely Sits
Radio Purple's analysis
The rule cuts eligibility, and USDA says so. The department's own analysis estimates 6.3 million people would no longer receive benefits in fiscal 2029. Those households are, by USDA's description, above SNAP's federal income or asset limits, which is the department's justification. Critics count the same people as losing help they need.
Some numbers in circulation overstate the effect. The figure of nearly 1.8 million children counts those who lose automatic eligibility for free school meals. USDA projects most would keep free meals after applying another way. The analysis estimates 28,000 would pay full price, though advocates warn some eligible families will fall through the cracks during the paperwork. And "non-cash" TANF benefits don't all stop counting: the federal definition of TANF "assistance" includes vouchers and, for families who are not employed, services such as child care and transportation.
The estimates carry uncertainty. USDA's analysis models other scenarios that shift the savings by billions of dollars in either direction. FRAC says the real impact will be larger.
What to watch: the comment total on the docket by Dec. 10; whether USDA changes the proposal in a final rule; the effective date it sets; and whether states or advocates challenge it in court. A similar 2019 proposal was withdrawn in 2021 and never took effect.
What the Right Says
The conservative and Republican case
USDA argues the policy has stretched a paperwork shortcut far beyond what Congress wrote.
In the rule, the department says broad-based eligibility "has compromised the statutory underpinnings of categorical eligibility" by qualifying "households who would not otherwise qualify based on the income and resource limits established in law." It says that in states with no asset test, "a household with a million dollars or more in available resources but no regular income could apply for and be eligible," and that it "is aware of instances where millionaires have received SNAP benefits."
The rule also says more than 840,000 one- and two-person households received the minimum benefit in 2024 only because of broad-based eligibility, "nearly $214 million" in benefits, and calls that spending out of line with "Congress' intent."
"Broad-based categorical eligibility has bloated the welfare rolls for decades," a USDA spokesperson said in a statement emailed to CBS News. "It has allowed states to take shortcuts, error rates to balloon, and those households with income and assets far above federal limits access to a benefit meant for the neediest among us. Correcting this loophole is long overdue."
White House spokeswoman Allison Schuster told CBS the administration wants SNAP to serve "eligible Americans who need it most."
We did not find statements from Republican members of Congress on this rule in searches of their posts and releases.
Sources & Citations
- Federal Register (USDA Food and Nutrition Administration), “Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program: Reforming Categorical Eligibility (proposed rule)”, November 10, 2026.
- GovInfo, “Proposed rule, official PDF (91 FR 72454)”, November 10, 2026.
- USDA via Regulations.gov, “Reforming Categorical Eligibility: Regulatory Impact Analysis (PDF)”, November 10, 2026.
- Regulations.gov, “Docket FNA-2026-0661”, November 10, 2026.
- Electronic Code of Federal Regulations, “45 CFR 260.31: What does the term 'assistance' mean?”, November 12, 2026.
- Federal Register, “Modification to Work Requirements for Able-Bodied Adults (proposed rule)”, November 10, 2026.
- CBS News, “New SNAP proposal would increase food insecurity for millions of Americans, critics say”, November 11, 2026.
- House Agriculture Committee Democrats, “Ranking Member Angie Craig Slams Trump Administration Effort to Kick an Additional 6.3 Million Americans off SNAP”, November 10, 2026.
- Office of Rep. Jahana Hayes, “Hayes Responds to Proposed Rule to Remove an Additional 6.3 Million Americans from SNAP”, November 10, 2026.
- Food Research & Action Center, “FRAC Calls Latest Proposal to Cut SNAP Another Attack on Hungry Americans”, November 10, 2026.
- Sen. Cory Booker (@SenBooker) on X, “Sen. Cory Booker on the proposed SNAP rule”, November 9, 2026.
- Center on Budget (@CenterOnBudget) on X, “Center on Budget and Policy Priorities on the proposed rule”, November 10, 2026.
Positions above are attributed to the public statements and published reporting cited here. Quotations are taken from these sources; Radio Purple does not publish unattributed or invented quotes. See an error? Request a correction.

