Senate Confirms 58th Trump Judge as GOP Races the Clock and Its Own Holdouts
Senate Republicans confirmed Daniel Domenico to the 10th Circuit on Monday, the 58th federal judge of Trump's second term. They're trying to fill more seats before Democrats take control in January, but a few Republican senators are using the blue slip to slow some picks.
By Daniel Whitaker, National Affairs
Published · Updated · 5 min read

The Overview
The facts, straight
Update, Nov. 18: The Senate confirmed Anna St. John to the Fifth Circuit on Tuesday, Nov. 17, by a 52-46 party-line vote (Roll Call Vote 265). That brings Article III confirmations in Trump's second term to 59, according to the Senate's list of confirmed nominations. This story has been updated with her confirmation, Tuesday's committee action and the pending-nominee count.
The Senate voted 51-46 on Monday to confirm U.S. District Judge Daniel Domenico of Colorado to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit. The roll call split along party lines: every Republican who voted said yes, and every Democrat and independent who voted said no. Domenico has been a federal trial judge since 2019, when President Donald Trump appointed him during his first term.
Domenico is the 58th Article III judge confirmed in Trump's second term. The Senate's list of confirmed nominations shows 11 appeals court judges, 46 district judges and one Court of International Trade judge confirmed since January 2025. The federal courts' own tally also shows 58.
Senate Majority Leader John Thune marked the milestone on X.
Days earlier, Thune posted this chart, as of Nov. 12: 57 confirmed, six nominees "teed up," zero "remaining on calendar."
What's left. Republicans keep the majority until Democrats take control in January (see our explainer on pro forma sessions and the lame-duck window). Here's where the remaining judicial picks stand in the official records:
- On the floor: The Senate confirmed Anna St. John, a Louisiana district judge, to the Fifth Circuit on Tuesday afternoon, 52-46 along party lines, per the Senate roll call. Four district court nominees, from Kentucky, Texas and Alaska, are still waiting for floor votes, according to Wednesday's executive calendar.
- In committee: The Senate Judiciary Committee's Tuesday meeting agenda listed five more district court nominees, from Florida, Louisiana, Missouri and Oklahoma. The committee reported the Florida, Louisiana and Missouri nominees to the floor Tuesday, according to Wednesday's executive calendar. The two Oklahoma nominees aren't on it. A nominations hearing is set for Wednesday.
- The overall count: The federal courts' vacancy pages list 27 current vacancies and 14 announced future ones. Those pages, last updated Nov. 17, still list 20 pending nominees, St. John among them, so about 19 remain after her confirmation. Reuters counted 23 pending nominees in a Nov. 15 report, a figure that included Domenico.
How much time is left is less clear. The Senate's tentative 2026 schedule takes Thanksgiving week off and starts the holiday break Dec. 21, which leaves about four working weeks. But the schedule was posted a year ago and is already off: the Senate held votes during a week it had marked as a break. We couldn't verify the "21 session days" figure that circulated online.
What the Left Says
The progressive and Democratic case
Senate Judiciary Committee ranking member Dick Durbin accused Republicans of cutting corners. "Judiciary Republicans have violated multiple committee norms to confirm their unqualified judicial nominees as fast as possible," he posted Monday as he spoke on the Senate floor. Last week he wrote that "lame-duck Republicans are so desperate to pack the courts before Democrats take control of the Senate that they're rushing to confirm a judge with active judicial misconduct charges pending against him." Durbin didn't name the judge in that post, and these are his allegations.
Democrats' core argument: these are lifetime appointments being pushed through after voters handed the Senate to Democrats. Every Democrat who voted opposed Domenico.
Where Reality Likely Sits
Radio Purple's analysis
Both parties use the lame duck. Democrats confirmed 27 judges in the 2014 lame duck and 22 after the 2024 election, according to Federal Judicial Center data. Republicans confirmed 14 after the 2020 election. Calling this session's push unprecedented doesn't hold up. The total depends on how many nominees clear committee in the next few weeks.
The blue slip is custom, not law. The Congressional Research Service notes that blue slips aren't in the Judiciary Committee's rules. The chair decides how much weight they get. Since 2017, the committee hasn't required them for appeals court nominees, but it still has for district court nominees. That's why this week's resistance centers on trial court seats in Texas and Oklahoma, not on the appeals court votes on the floor.
Unfilled seats wait for the next Senate. Vacancies without confirmed judges carry over into January, when a Democratic majority will decide which nominees get hearings. This is the live question for the next four weeks: how many of the roughly 19 remaining nominees get votes. Watch the floor votes on the seven district nominees now waiting, the two Oklahoma picks still in committee and Wednesday's hearing.
What we couldn't verify. Claims online that Trump wants the blue slip abolished, and that Republican voters are angry the SAVE America Act stalled while judges advanced, came from news summaries and anonymous accounts. We found no posts from the officials themselves backing either claim, so we've left them out.
What the Right Says
The conservative and Republican case
Republicans call it finishing the job. "We're turning judicial nominations into confirmations at the fastest pace since the Reagan administration," Thune wrote Monday. Judiciary Committee Chairman Chuck Grassley posted average nomination-to-confirmation times: 83 days in Trump's second term, compared with 138 under President Joe Biden, 213 in Trump's first term and 217 under President Barack Obama.
Those are Grassley's figures. We ran a rough check using the Federal Judicial Center's judges database, counting from nomination to confirmation for district and appeals judges. Our numbers came out differently but point the same way: about 78 days on average in Trump's second term, compared with 56 under Reagan, 99 under George H.W. Bush, 118 under Biden, 158 in Trump's first term and 176 under Obama.
Vice President JD Vance also pushed for speed. In a TV interview clip his office posted Monday night, he said: "we have a lot of nominations, a lot of good judges that have lifetime appointments that have to get confirmed."
Republicans also point to precedent. After Democrats lost the Senate in the 2014 midterms, the outgoing Democratic majority confirmed 27 of Obama's district judges between Nov. 13 and Dec. 16, 2014, including 12 on the final day, according to Federal Judicial Center records.
Some resistance is coming from Republicans. A White House official told Reuters, "We expect all judicial nominees pending in the Senate to be confirmed this year." But some GOP senators are using the blue slip, the form home-state senators return to the Judiciary Committee, to slow certain picks:
- Texas: Sen. John Cornyn, who lost his primary, has declined to commit to supporting T. Elliot Gaiser, who heads the Justice Department's Office of Legal Counsel, for a federal judgeship in Dallas, Reuters reported. A Cornyn aide told Bloomberg Law that Cornyn is recommending former federal prosecutor Steve Fahey instead.
- Oklahoma: Sen. Alan Armstrong initially returned a favorable blue slip for nominee Zach West but later withdrew his support, according to Reuters.
- North Carolina's Thom Tillis isn't withholding a blue slip himself. As a retiring committee member, he is using his vote to back his colleagues' objections. "When I've got two Republicans from the state telling me to move on it, I move on it," Tillis told reporters, according to Reuters. "If I have one or more asking me not to, then I'm not."
Separately, the White House withdrew Lee Rudofsky's nomination to the Eighth Circuit and replaced him with Arkansas Supreme Court Justice Cody Hiland after Arkansas' two Republican senators objected, Reuters reported.
Sources & Citations
- U.S. Senate, “Roll Call Vote 119th Congress, 2nd Session, Vote No. 263: Domenico nomination”, November 16, 2026.
- U.S. Senate, “Roll Call Vote 119th Congress, 2nd Session, Vote No. 265: St. John nomination”, November 17, 2026.
- U.S. Senate, “Roll Call Votes, 119th Congress, 2nd Session”, November 16, 2026.
- U.S. Senate, “Nominations Confirmed (Civilian)”, November 16, 2026.
- U.S. Senate, “Executive Calendar, Tuesday, November 17, 2026”, November 17, 2026.
- Senate Judiciary Committee, “Executive Business Meeting, November 17, 2026”, November 17, 2026.
- Administrative Office of the U.S. Courts, “Current Judicial Vacancies”, November 16, 2026.
- Administrative Office of the U.S. Courts, “Future Judicial Vacancies”, November 16, 2026.
- Federal Judicial Center, “Biographical Directory of Article III Federal Judges (data export)”, November 17, 2026.
- U.S. Senate, “Tentative 2026 Legislative Schedule”, November 21, 2025.
- Congressional Research Service, “The Blue Slip Process for U.S. Circuit and District Court Nominations (1917-Present)”, November 17, 2026.
- Reuters, “Trump's judge appointment blitz faces Republican resistance”, November 15, 2026.
- Bloomberg Law, “Cornyn Seeks Alternative to Late Trump Judge Pick in Texas”, November 16, 2026.
Positions above are attributed to the public statements and published reporting cited here. Quotations are taken from these sources; Radio Purple does not publish unattributed or invented quotes. See an error? Request a correction.

